What is Return of Capital in real estate private equity and how does it work?
If you’ve invested in real estate private equity and seen a distribution labeled “Return of Capital” (ROC), you’re not alone if you thought:
“Is this a profit distribution…or am I just getting my money back?”
“If I got capital back, why did my monthly distribution go down?”
“How does ROC affect the preferred return and the waterfall?”
“Is ROC taxable?”
This post breaks it down in plain English with the nuances that actually matter.
What is Return of Capital?
Return of Capital (ROC) is cash paid back to investors that is treated as a repayment of their original principal, not profit.
Think of it this way:
Return of capital = getting some of your original chips back
Return on capital = winnings (profit)
Importantly, you can often receive ROC and still retain ownership in the investment (depending on the governing documents).
What Return of Capital is not
ROC is usually not:
A full liquidation
The end of the investment
A sign the investment is “bad”
Automatically taxable (more on taxes below)
ROC can happen in healthy outcomes—but it isn’t a guarantee of success. Sometimes ROC happens because a deal refinanced after strong performance; other times it can happen for structural reasons (like returning unused capital or rebalancing a portfolio).
Common ways ROC happens in real estate private equity
ROC typically comes from one of three places:
1) Refinance
A property refinances (often after it appreciates or stabilizes), and some proceeds are distributed to investors as ROC.
2) Recapitalization
A new equity partner comes in or the capital structure changes, and existing investors receive some capital back.
3) Sale
A property is sold and the proceeds are distributed. Often the distribution includes:
ROC (your original principal coming back), and
Profit (return on capital)
ROC in a single-property syndication vs. a multi-asset fund
This is where many investors (understandably) get tripped up.
Single-property syndication (one asset)
ROC often comes from a refinance.
Investors still own the same property afterward.
Cash flow might drop due to higher debt service (explained below).
Multi-asset fund (many assets)
ROC can show up more ways:
Sale proceeds from one asset may be distributed as ROC even while the fund continues operating through other assets.
Some funds reinvest sale/refi proceeds into new deals; others distribute them.
The label “ROC” is often tied to how the fund’s Operating Agreement requires cash to be classified and how capital accounts are tracked.
In other words: in a fund, ROC might reflect what happened in one part of the portfolio, while the overall fund continues.
Example 2: ROC inside a multi-asset fund (why it feels different)
Assume you invest $100,000 into a fund that owns 10 properties.
Nine properties keep operating normally
One property sells in Year 3
Year 3: one asset sells
When the fund sells one property, the fund receives net proceeds. Per the fund’s Operating Agreement and reporting policy, part of that distribution may be labeled:
$15,000 Return of Capital (ROC) to you
Plus (potentially) some profit distribution, depending on the sale result and the waterfall
Now your unreturned capital for reporting purposes might go from $100,000 → $85,000.
Why your monthly distribution might drop afterward
Even though the fund still owns nine properties, the sold property is no longer contributing cash flow. If that sold property was a meaningful income contributor, the fund’s total distributable cash flow can drop.
Also, if the fund doesn’t immediately reinvest those proceeds into a new cash-flowing asset, the fund may temporarily have:
less cash flow producing assets, and/or
more cash sitting idle (often by design for timing/reserve reasons)
Bottom line: In a fund, ROC can occur even though “the fund is still going,” because it’s tied to the economics and accounting of portfolio events.
Why ROC can be a good thing
ROC is often beneficial because it can:
Reduce principal at risk (less of your original investment remains exposed)
Increase flexibility (you can redeploy capital elsewhere)
Improve capital efficiency (you may still own the investment but now have less capital tied up)
This is why investors sometimes say ROC is like “taking chips off the table while staying in the game.”
Why distributions/cash flow often drop after a Return of Capital
This is the most common question—and the most misunderstood.
If ROC came from a refinance…
A refinance often means:
Higher loan balance
Higher interest expense / debt service
Often higher lender reserve requirements (capex reserves, TI/LC reserves, escrows, etc.)
If property income stays roughly the same but debt service goes up, cash available for distribution typically goes down.
That’s not necessarily a “problem.” It’s the tradeoff of pulling capital out earlier.
If ROC came from a sale…
If an asset is sold, its cash flow is gone. In a fund, the remaining assets may still produce distributions—but the overall cash flow can be lower if the sold asset was contributing meaningful income.
Another common driver: reinvestment/upgrades
Sometimes operators intentionally retain cash for:
upgrades/capex
lease-up
adding units
operational improvements
That can reduce near-term distributions while improving long-term value.
Example 1: ROC from a refinance (single-asset syndication)
Starting point
You invest $100,000
The deal has an 8% cumulative preferred return, calculated on unreturned capital
Year 1 and 2 cash flow is light during stabilization
Years 1–2 (before ROC)
Year 1 distributions: $5,000 (5%)
Pref “target” (8% of $100k) = $8,000
$3,000 of unpaid pref is tracked as an arrearage (because it’s cumulative)
Year 2 distributions: $6,000 (6%)
Pref target = $8,000
Another $2,000 arrearage is added
At the end of Year 2, the investor has received $11,000 of distributions and has $5,000 of accrued unpaid pref.
Year 3: refinance creates ROC
The property refinances after the NOI improves and the loan market allows it. The refinance generates proceeds and the deal distributes:
$30,000 Return of Capital (ROC) to you (your principal coming back)
Ongoing monthly distributions drop because the new debt service is higher:
Year 3 distributions: $4,200 (instead of ~$6,000)
What changed (and why investors notice it)
Your “capital at risk” fell:
Unreturned capital goes from $100,000 → $70,000
That’s often a good thing.
Your preferred return hurdle going forward is lower:
Pref now accrues on $70,000, not $100,000
New annual pref target = $5,600 (8% × $70,000)
Your cash flow dropped for a normal reason:
Higher debt service and/or higher lender reserves means less distributable cash
The deal didn’t “break” — the capital structure changed.
The unpaid pref didn’t disappear:
The prior $5,000 arrearage still exists (if the pref is cumulative)
It’s typically addressed later per the waterfall (often meaningfully at sale/refi events)
Bottom line: ROC often lowers risk and can improve IRR, but it may also reduce ongoing distributions because the deal now has more debt (or fewer cash-flowing assets).
Most funds aren’t choosing between “keep the dollar payment the same” vs. “keep the percentage the same”—distributions are largely driven by actual net cash available, and the Operating Agreement determines how that cash is allocated and reported.
How ROC interacts with preferred returns and the waterfall
Preferred return basics
In many real estate private equity structures, limited partners (LPs) receive a preferred return before the general partner (GP) participates in profits.
Most commonly, the preferred return is calculated on “unreturned capital.”
So if you invest $100,000 and later receive $25,000 of ROC, the preferred return may then accrue on $75,000 going forward.
But: preferred return mechanics vary by deal. Some calculate pref differently, including IRR-based hurdles or other definitions of “invested capital.” The governing documents control.
A key point investors miss
Investors sometimes assume the fund can choose between:
keeping the same dollar distribution after ROC, or
keeping the same percentage distribution after ROC
In reality, distributions are usually driven by actual net cash available.
If cash flow declines after a refinance (due to higher debt service), the fund often cannot keep the same dollar payment without using reserves or taking on additional risk.
And if the Operating Agreement defines distributions and capital accounts in a specific way, the fund may also have limited discretion in how those payments are treated in the waterfall.
What about a 100% Return of Capital?
This surprises people:
In a debt investment, if you get your principal back, the investment is usually over.
In an equity investment, it’s possible to receive 100% of your capital back and still retain an ownership interest (again, depending on the governing docs).
If that happens, investors may still participate in future cash flow and appreciation—often under the standard profit split (e.g., 80/20), even though their “capital at risk” is largely or entirely recovered.
That can be an outstanding outcome.
Is Return of Capital taxable?
Usually, ROC is not taxable at the time it’s received—up to your tax basis.
Instead, it typically reduces your basis in the investment.
When can it become taxable?
ROC can be taxable if:
Distributions exceed your tax basis (often taxed as capital gain)
The distribution is treated as a sale or exchange under special circumstances
One nuance: taxes don’t always match cash labels
Even if a distribution is labeled “ROC,” you can still have taxable income in a given year because of:
property operations
depreciation and allocations
gains triggered by a sale
depreciation recapture
other partnership tax items
That’s why your K-1 (not the “ROC” label alone) is what ultimately determines your tax reporting.
Important: This post is general education, not tax advice. Investors should consult their tax advisor for their specific situation.
Accounting and reporting: why the label can feel confusing
“Return of Capital” is often used as a reporting and capital-account concept, not a perfect descriptor of economics.
Most investors see ROC in:
investor statements / portal reporting
capital account rollforwards
fund financial statements
In general:
ROC reduces an investor’s capital account / remaining invested capital.
Preferred return and waterfalls are often calculated off those capital balances per the agreement.
But the exact presentation depends on:
the fund’s governing documents
its accounting policy and reporting format
tax allocations vs. book allocations (which can differ)
Final thoughts: ROC is usually a feature, not a bug
Return of Capital is a normal (and often positive) phase in the lifecycle of a real estate private equity investment.
ROC can reduce risk by returning principal.
ROC can improve capital efficiency by freeing cash for reinvestment.
ROC can change future cash flow, especially after refinances and asset sales.
ROC affects preferred returns and waterfalls based on the governing docs.
ROC is usually not taxable immediately, but tax outcomes depend on basis and K-1 items.
If you ever have questions about ROC in a specific fund, the most helpful next step is to review:
the Operating Agreement/LPA waterfall language, and
the capital account statement/reporting, and
the K-1 and basis implications with your tax advisor.
If you have any questions, please contact us or use this link to schedule a call with us.
DISCLAIMER: Past performance is not indicative of future results. There is no guarantee that any forecasts or projections will be achieved. Any investment involves significant risk, including the possible loss of principal. Investors should carefully consider the investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses of any Wellings Capital Management, LLC (“Wellings”) investment program. Offering documents containing this and other important information are available by calling 800.844.2188, emailing invest@wellingscapital.com, or visiting wellingscapital.investnext.com.
The information in this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any securities in any jurisdiction where such an offer or solicitation would be unlawful. Wellings is an SEC-registered investment advisor, however Wellings does not provide tax, legal, or accounting advice. Investors should consult their own advisors regarding any investment. Information and any opinions contained in this article have been obtained from sources that we consider reliable, but we do not represent that such information and opinions are accurate or complete and thus should not be relied upon as such.